Well, if you have to buy new, I'd say the Yaesu as well. It's pretty damn nice, great ergonomics.
Also, if you could handle the idea of a used rig, there are some amazing radios for the $$.
Personally, I'm not a huge Icom fan. They are OK, but when I've spent time with them, they didn't impress me as much as other rigs. No chance you'd consider a Flex, Ten Tec, or Elecraft?
Just wondering.