Results 1 to 9 of 9

Thread: New antenna suggestions?

  1. #1
    Pope Carlo l NQ6U's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Maritime Mobile
    Posts
    29,873

    New antenna suggestions?

    It's been pretty windy here today and a big gust just just blew in from the southeast and pulled apart the G5RV Jr. I put up immediately after getting my general ticket. Not really a big loss, the G5RV Jr. wasn't a great performer (not even resonant on any ham band) and I'd been thinking about replacing it with something else anyhow.

    I already have a dual band wire antenna for 20m/40m and have been thinking about something for either 15m or 30m—perhaps a trapped dipole for both? There isn't enough distance between the trees I've been using as supports for anything below 30m.

    Suggestions are solicited.
    All the world’s a stage, but obviously the play is unrehearsed and everybody is ad-libbing his lines. Maybe that’s why it’s hard to tell if we’re living in a tragedy or a farce.

  2. #2
    Whacker Knot WØTKX's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Lakewood, CO
    Posts
    26,758
    Umm, maybe a ladder line fed loop with a tuner?

    An inverted "L" maybe?

    Love to hear you on the lower bands in the winter.
    "Where would we be without the agitators of the world to attach the electrodes
    of knowledge to the nipples of ignorance?" ~ Professor "Dick" Soloman



  3. #3
    Orca Whisperer
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Buffalo, NY
    Posts
    22,593
    I'm a big fan of...

    fan dipoles. hahaha

    I don't know the math, but it seems traps are lossier than the "extra legs" on the dipoles, and my fan has served me well for 3 bands. I know they get quite fickle the more bands you add though.
    Big Giant Meteor 2020 - We need to make Earth Great Again

    http://www.coreyreichle.com

  4. #4
    "Usual Suspect" WZ7U's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    CN86jc
    Posts
    5,452
    The question becomes about the space you do have when considering antenna choices. Everyone has their pet methods of launching electrons and with antennas size does matter. Of course you know all this already..... it comes down to what you need to keep yourself happy in this hobby.

    For some of us (myself included in this) spare funds play into it. Personally I'm not afraid of 'repurposing' things others think of as trash. For example, today the yl had me helping her in the yard just going around picking out the stuff that needed to feed the garbage dump. She has a thing for using strings of white/clear christmas lights as outdoor lighting, so they usually only last a year or so. I spent a bit of time picking out the good wire so when time comes to experiment with a new variation of antenna, I won't have to use the debit card to pick up a roll of wire. Right now my time is of such little value I can afford to take the effort to do this while visiting with the yl while she is repotting plants out in the yard on a nice sunday afternoon. I get the attaboys for hanging out and being social while replenishing my stock of cheap experiment stock. A win/win in my book. Besides, she is updating her light stock with LEDs every year at the after christmas sales so I'm in wire for a while to come.

    So, I'm partial to low hung loops on the low bands because I like the way they propagate (nvis). Verticals are ok for low angle dx on a budget although I need to get another to replace the one lost in the move. Simple dipoles work ok too, it's all in what keeps you happy right? I wish I could afford a tall tower and a monster beam but I'm ok without it. I do need to find a guy that will climb some taller trees for a reasonable fee so I can get my wires up higher this time. I hope you can come up with a solution that meets your criteria without becoming a pain in the ass for ya. If there is one thing I ALWAYS hear guys go on about, it's antennas.

    Keep us updated, will ya? I love yakking antennas.

    Like that post was...
    Moving on, my posts are not helpful

  5. #5
    SK Member 04/29/2020 w2amr's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    National Park N.J.
    Posts
    16,259
    I have a 6 band, ground mounted butternut vertical, with sixteen 20" counterpoise wires. I recently installed the 12 and 17 meter add on kits. I love it.

  6. #6
    Orca Whisperer W3WN's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Location
    Castle Shannon, PA
    Posts
    19,316
    Quote Originally Posted by w2amr View Post
    I have a 6 band, ground mounted butternut vertical, with sixteen 20" counterpoise wires. I recently installed the 12 and 17 meter add on kits. I love it.
    Can you say... HF6V?

    I've been running one of those for many, many moons. Got my first one back when I worked in the local ham store, from Mr. Butternut [Don Newcomb WØDN (SK)] himself. It survived many moves, getting turned into a pretzel once, and performed very well up until the end.

    I'm on my second one, which was willed to me from the estate of a SK. (Well, technically it's my third one; I had a second one I picked up used, ended up selling it to a local ham who used it on many DXpeditions).

    Still have the original one; it's currently sitting in storage, along with the HF2V. "B" tube broke on me. My fault, actually; during one of the moves, I didn't install the base correctly, wind caused some damage due to my error. NB3C was kind enough to take the tube into work (USAir at the time) and due an aluminum weld to repair the damage. The weld is what gave way... over 10 years later. I have a new "B" tube, I just never got around to dismantling the antenna to replace the tube. One of these days, though, I will.
    “Nobody is going to feel sorry for us. 90% of the people don’t care, the other 10% are glad it happened.” — Clint Hurdle, 2019

    BAN THE DH!

    Fudd's First Law of Opposition: If you push something hard enough, it WILL fall down.
    Teslacle's Deviant to Fudd's Law: It goes in, it must go out.

    Just remember: Abraham Lincoln didn't die in vain. He died in Washington, DC

    Cutch 2K!!

    “Nero fiddled while Rome burned. Trump golfed.” — Bernie Sanders

    Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati


  7. #7
    Lord of the Flies kb2crk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Location
    arnoldsville ga
    Posts
    4,124
    Can always use a Fractal


    a yankee living in the hind end of the bible belt
    some people are like slinkys, not really good for anything, but still bring a smile to your face when you push them down the stairs.

  8. #8
    The Fluid of Spock KD8TUT's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2016
    Location
    Lake Michigan Beach MI
    Posts
    2,194
    Quote Originally Posted by K6BSO View Post
    It's been pretty windy here today and a big gust just just blew in from the southeast and pulled apart the G5RV Jr. I put up immediately after getting my general ticket. Not really a big loss, the G5RV Jr. wasn't a great performer (not even resonant on any ham band) and I'd been thinking about replacing it with something else anyhow.

    I already have a dual band wire antenna for 20m/40m and have been thinking about something for either 15m or 30m—perhaps a trapped dipole for both? There isn't enough distance between the trees I've been using as supports for anything below 30m.

    Suggestions are solicited.
    I've had good results with off-center fed windoms- usually in an inverted V. I've got two, one that is a resonant 80/40/20 sort of antenna. And another which is 40/20/10/6. Can tune them to usability on any of the bands with the loss that comes along with it.

    The 80 meter one is something like 134ft. And the 40 is something like 73ft. Heights are 40ft and 30 ft.

    Not going to claim these are a panacea. However, I'm very happy.

    In my short tenure as a ham, I've grown to respect resonant wire antennas a lot more than I had expected to. They certainly can perform.

  9. #9
    Newbie KD5OEI's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2016
    Location
    Dallas, Texas
    Posts
    14
    I've a nice dipole made of bare wire ladder line (both conductors serving as one 'wire' of a leg), some 65FT or so in length per leg.

    It has four legs, two for each 'side' and two are slightly longer than the other two which makes it a little broader, I guess. So it is a kind of fan dipole I suppose. It's a Tekrad, very old, not made any more. Found it new in the box at a fest for $10. tekrad mark V.jpg

    It is fed by an integral section of the same open wire line. This is run into the shack to the back of the tuner. The tuner is an MFJ 989. The "3KW" 989 adequate for SSB but for high duty modes @ QRO the ceramic trimmer used for calibration on the measurement board has to be replaced with something better like a small air trimmer because it will arc and burn.

    A 1:1 current balun is used from the tuner's coaxial output to the open wire transmission line. This works well and tunes all bands 80-10 fairly easily. It's a bit sharp on 80M. I had used a 4:1 previously but it caused high current on the SO239s. Results are more satisfactory with a 1:1. The point is that I do not use the tuner's internal balun.

    I'm no expert on antennas but this has not given me any trouble.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •